Comments (None yet)

Add New Comment

7 corrections, most recently by BobC - Show corrections






"A team of cripples, with not the slightest   chance if winning," was the opinion of many       Essendon men as to their own prospects at Fitz-   roy last Saturday. In addition to Forbes and   Officer, both gone in the ankles, they found at the last minute that neither Vautin nor O'Loghlen     could, with any claim to wisdom, take part in   the match, and with half a dozen good men miss- ing it did look a hopeless undertaking for Essen-   don. Two things have to be considered, however,   and admitting Essendon weaker than usual, they forgot to reckon the from of the other side, who had Cleary and M'Micheal, their captain and vice-     captain, still looking on, and Banks leading     them once more. When Essendon started by     getting first goal with a long angle shot by Thur-   good—a relative of their famous goal-kicker of other years—the spectators thought it a flash in     the pan, and declared that Fitzroy would come       with a rush in a minute. The rush was delayed   rather more than a minute—so long, indeed, that     the descendants of Cyclops, who haunt the local     press-box, found the Essendon Ulysses putting     their eye out in "the same old" emphatic fashion. Up to three-quarter time Essendon had         been doing most of the work, and doing it in the     best style, so that for two-thirds of the time the       play was in the Fitzroy ground. Yet all along         one had the impression that Fitzroy was really           the stronger twenty, but was playing badly. On     this last point three could be no mistake. They           seemed altogether disorganised, were fumbling far     more than was excusably and putting in a great   amount of hard work to little purpose. With   Fitzroy it was a case of plug-plug-plug, which one of Essendon's old meteoric dashes more than   counterbalanced. With an advantage of 35 points             to 9 at the last change Essendon had the game is     hand, but they either made the common mistake     of suddenly converting a brilliant attack into a defence, or were run to a standstill by their     earlier excretions. At any rate, they were soundly   beaten in the last quarter, and during that stage,    

at any rate, Fitzroy showed the form expected of   them. With a little lack they would have re- duced the difference in points quickly, for four     successive shots went in the same spot, just a yard     outside goal. Essendon got one useful hint—as         well as a gallantly won, if unexpected, victory—   viz., that it is unwise to change wining tactics.  

Some teams—like the combatants in the greater       game of international politics—must be agressive   to be effected, and when Essendon adopted the   Gladstonian policy of simply seeking to hold what they had gained, they dropped in an instant       form brilliancy to modernity. Hood, again, um-         pired a good game, and in a few matches has   shown himself indisputably the right man for the          


Essendon rejoiced in once more having their game little follower, Gus Kearney, with them, and the game has not left him behind, for he was one of Essendon's three best men from start to finish- the other two being, in my opinion. An- derson and Kinnear. Anderson has that quality possessed by M'Ginis, of Melbourne, more than any other player I know of always finishing up with a fine long drop-kick. Kinnear was a deter-     mined little worker all through. Wright, as usual, was a better man at the start than the finish ; and George Stuckey made many fine dashes, which in the attacking stage, told greatly for the side. Waugh was another of Essendon's light heeled clippers, who showed that brain is mostly a match for muscle. He and Thurgood each got two goals. Martin showed admirable form back just when Essendon most needed him. Darcy back, and Salkeld, Barry, and Cleghorn were useful men to their side. Fitzroy's defence was the more even     of the two- so strong, indeed, that looking back at the game one wonders at the result. Reid was playing a sure and fast game; Banks re- liable as usual; while Muirhead. Hickey, and Dalton were a fine half-back line while they were kept together. Muirhead I look upon as one of the best little men in the Fitzroy team-an un- tiring worker. If Fitzroy backs were strong, their forwards were all to pieces, Kiernan being, perhaps, the one exception D. Moriarty played a good game in the centre, where Fitzroy were generally beaten, and in their ruck the best work was done by M. Grace and Sloane.


When South Melbourne found themselves so much   at sea in the opening game of the season, they       talked wildly about going back to old rules. That   topic exhausted, it occurred to them that if the     game couldn't be made to suit South Melbourne,       South Melbourne might be made to suit the game.     There they were on safe ground, and their captain         had a much easier task than would have awaited       Mr. Sloss had he determined to induce the V.F.L.     to revert to little marks and suicide. After being routed by Melbourne and just squeezing home team           Carlton, South Melbourne have adapted the mesives         to the new conditions so throughly that they are         once again the formidable South, feet of foot and       shrewd of head. This shows good management             somewhere-and I dare say more than one aid lead       contributed to it. When they met Collingwood on       Saturday it was a fine interesting game for three   quarters, though in the last stage little better than     a catch-as-catch-can wrestling bout. The umpire,               a young fellow named Smith, had not the moral           away so essential in a grand where many men adept       in the art of umpire-blaming were engaged, and           I wonder that the league entrusted it to a novice.        

With a faster and firmer umpire Collingwood         thought they might have done a bit better, at the     same time they admit that even on goals did not     in this case mean even on merit, and that the         North well deserved to win by them advantage on     behinds. The only objectionable feature in         the match was the conduct of the mode of           howling maniacs who call themselves Southern    

supporters. As a fact, they support nothing but the conviction that, uncontrolled, they would in time make it impossible for decent people to attend football matches. Their conduct towards the umpire especially made it very difficult for that un-

fortunate official to do his work.    

Those who contributed mainly to South Mel-       bourne strength in the centre. Howson, and       Waugh, the last-named having a very counterable               position, for Strickland had to leave him un-     guarded so often when rounding up         players that the popular Foddie did a lot in his     own neat way. Howson was simply the cleverest         place man on the ground. Taking it all though,     Gibson was perhaps the South's most strongest             man in the ruck, but Purdy gave great help at   the outset, and Pleas in the later stages. M'Kay's       marking was very fine in this he gave all hands a lead- and Windley roved with that consummate           coolness so effective with him. Blackwood's mark-     ing was the best thing froward, and D. Adamson   was the pick of a bounce of good back men. Those     of the Collingwood team who were strongest     against Geelong were nowhere at South Melbourne.       Condon and M'Donald played very effectively to- gether, at times the last-named chiefly doing the                 helping, while Condon did not always miss his op-             portunity wisely. His judgement, though, in going for a high mark, is just about as nice as one sees in football. Little Dowdell brushed up a   good deal in the later stages, when, with the   players all in a heap, the conditions reminded him,           perhaps of last season. Sime was the best of their     middle men, and Proudfoot, Monahan, and Wil-     liams, though useful back men, were not brilliant,         Dow playing the cleverest game there towards the       fiish, Hailwood, who has been out of form,   showed improvement when tured out in the ruck,   and both Tame and Tulloch were useful.      


St. Kilda are not to be despised, despite their   poor showing against Southern Queen's Birthday,   and before the sheep and goats are drafted at the     end of the fourteenth pound they may humble one or two who are now rejoining in their strength. Up to half time they were not in it with fly-       ing Melbourne, but afterwards they were very much in it, and gave twenty hilings change for   every sovereign the Reds could produce. In the first half the points were 42 to 19 in favour of Melbourne, in the second 31 to 27, and of the     Melbourne points a dozen were got in the form of two goals just before the bell rang. Melbourne,       now the only unbeaten team in the league, ex-       celled, as usual, in those clever exchanges at      

which they are transfer, and when Moysey and

Co. were hand tossing it one to another the St.  

Kilda fellows were giddy with spinning round so continuously and getting nothing out of their         humming top exhibition except a feeling that the   elm trees round the ground were running races.       The Saints played a slogging game, each one           throwing himself into it heart and soul. The     sum total was one of the prettiest matches of the  

season a model in these qualities of fair play         and generosity which lift a game above the aver-   age. Could we get football of that was every        

Saturday, we might indeed boast of the virtues             of Australian rules. In addition to the advantages             I have already mentioned. Melbourne were a bit          

more clever in the close play. Two men on the     side showed exceptional form M'Ginis and       Woods- the Tasmanian favouring them with some       of his most attractive football, while Wood's daz-      

zling rushes from the half-back line greatly mul-         tiplied his admirers. Lewis was much too good     for Shaw in the centre-the double duty of watch-         ing his opponent and his team being a heavy han-              

dicap to the St. Kilda flier. Shehan was gene-

                        rally faster than the clever Matthews in the dart     for the ball, though, on the other wing, Mitchell       found himself out witted and outpaced by a clever     Cumloden boy named Beggs. Moysey, as I have     said, played handball to perfection, and if I call         little Robinson an effective skiirter, it means some-         thing much more complimentary than when Mr.           Godfrey Watson applies it to one of his foxhounds. Herring, Moodey, and Young played nicely, but     Moysey had the lead in goal-kicking, as he re-         counted for 3, while Moysey and M'Ginis got 3       each. Aylwin and Hogan were again St. Kilda's       two crack backs, the former being very sure,       while Hogan rarely missed a mark and as the   Melbourne men sought less to baulk him than heat           him in fair soaring. Hogan had every chance to     show his powers. The young collegian, M'Grath, also played a useful game. Jennings was clever     in the ground play. One of the St. Kilda backs-     Phillips- has a record, in that he has only missed     one game in 74, the South Melbourne match       being his exception. Can any footballer beat that?     M'Leod showed an intimate knowledge of all the   tricky points of football- and a disposition to talk from bounce to bell. Ahern did some nice mark-   ing, and scored 2 goals, and M. Blake, as one of   his comrades put it, carried the first goal "with       a regular Irish rush," while D. Dunn, R. Stewart, and Hay were all prominent.


The conditions at Geelong being favourable to       a good game, were accentuated by the masterly     manner in which M'Coy, as umpire, handled it.    

The Geelong people were quite charmed with his   tact and pace, and, with both sides playing good   football in a fine, open-spirited game, the players     could be trusted with a high rein. Geelong had a good deal the best of it in the first half, for, with Young, Jos and James M'Shane, and Parkin   all playing at their best, the Geelong, followers       were a bit too big for the light, active lot who now compare the Carlton twenty. Geelong, how- ever, are still weak forward-otherwise they   have shown a better result in goals. After half- time Carlton played a much better gamee, but? lind

not their atro-uctt tmutv doun. The tncn.l liuvi..

already named did good work for Geelong all through, and with them may be bracketed M'Cal-

lum, who was speedy as usual ; James, who both back and forward was in first-rate form, and   scored 3 goals ; Flynn, of whose forward play Gee-   long are more than enamoured ; Pontin, who maintained his reputation as a safe half-back ; and Conway, who improved on his past games. On Carlton's back lines, Reckie was at his best, and   Walton and Lyons gave generous aid. The Blues, too, played a good centre line, where Casey and Armstrong were conspicuous. In the close play Aitken, Breeze, and Hannah worked very hard, and Chapman, a new man in the colours, proved a gain to the side, whether playing forward or on the ball.



Port Melbourne have been flattering themselves

with the prospect of going through the season without a defeat, and when a team lull themselves lo sleep with this soothing conviction the awaken-   ing is sure to be a rude one. When they met North Melbourne on Saturday they found their strongest move-the handball-repeatedly and effec- tually checked by the smartness of the other side, and, thus baulked, played a bit wildly, and lost their places. Finding unity of one sort ineffec-   tive, they went to the other extreme and sought by individual effort to run over or through their opponents, with consequences further disastrous.

The crowning achievement of North Melbourne was in the last quarter, for within 12 minutes of time it was either side's game. Then, with a spirit   that should serve them well in future games, the North simply ran over their toes, and in an in- credibly brief space, one of their forwards (Barty)

had covered himself with glory by snapping three goals in quick succession, while a fourth was got from a place kick. The paralysing rally settled the       issue beyond all question, and the Ports woke up and rubbed their eyes hard. The result was the more creditable to the North in that they were short of men at the outset, and had to force in a couple of cripples to complete their eighteen. The best man on the side of the winners was, per- haps, Caldwell, whose play on the back lines created a first-rate impression, E Launder, as   usual, being a staunch assistant. Next to   Caldwell, however, the two best men in the team were play and H. Launder, both of them playing rattling good football. Rutley, Oates, Houston,   Quilligan, Montgomerie, Stuckey, and Graham were   all useful. Port Melbourne missed their active little forward. Rowan, who was knocked out in     the Footscray match. Monagle-a most determined   little worker-was about the pick of their team,

assisted by Daly, Powell, and Shannon forward, Hickey on the wing, and Freame back.  


As invariable happens when Footscray and Wil-  

liamstown meet, the crowd was a good one, and the interest keen. Latterly, however, both teams have shown their good sense in dropping the old feeling of personal hostility, while sacrificing little in healthy rivalry-and there was nothing in the game to which one could take exception. It lost interest only in that Footscray was, from the out-   set, palpably the stronger twenty. The Williams-   town backs were certainly too good for the men who opposed them, but in every other part of the field they were beaten, their centre line especially being quite unable to cope with the fast combination Footscray had   placed there. The exception was M'Williams,  

who did all that could reasonable be expected of him ; but on the other hand, Footscray's wing  

man, Williams, had no rival on the field in a   place, and Dick was one of their three best, while a colt named M'Carthy played first-rate football     at halfback. Footscray's half-forward line was     thoroughly sound, Grundon, Gregory, and Dickins being a reliable lot. Brockwell stood head and shoulders over the rest of the ruck, and Dean played in his usual hard, never-say-die fashion when following. M'Callum was the clipper of the   Williamstown backs, Dyson and Riley likewise shining as defenders. They were so strong there that they were able to send Hall on the ball, but he was less efficient than when watching his own

goal. Warren and Fagan had their share of the   "strum and drang."    


The Brunswick ground is a peculiar one, and

visiting clubs have to study its geographical features closely if they wish to succeed. Richmond would have overcome this difficulty on Saturday, and brought away the points, but for the fact   that the ball was always going outside the goal-  

posts for them, and just as persistently inside for Brunswick. "Four goals 15 behinds" is a Rich-  

mond record that tells its own story, but their kicking was not so hopelessly bad as it looks, for a good many of those behinds were rushed, instead of being the minor outcome of deliberate shots for goal, while two of their tries hit the goal-post.   Brunswick, however, did more than shoot ac- curately. They were with Richmond all through   in the general play, and their greater weight was     used with telling, though legitimate, effect. In

the first half most of the Richmond men seemed partly asleep, and when they woke up the game       was lost. The high marking of the winners was     another good feature in their play, their tall fel- lows going up for the ball very often, and gene- rally getting it. Johnson and O'Loghlen again     played sterling football for the winners, and Hill-   yer, who scored three goals, was a useful forward.      

Others seen to marked advantage were "the three         Macs" -M'Namara, M'Cormack, and M'Donald-         Whelan. Gordon, and Sampson. Parker was the   best man in yellow and black , but the side lost     a good little one in Ryan, who is on the casualty   list. Backhouse used his weight and pace with customary effect in the centre, while Harris, Elder, Hayes, and Watson fought valiantly for a   lost cause. Hayes and Elder each got two goals.      


1st 2nd -3rd

Match Qtr. Qtr. Qtr Final Pts.


Geelong . . . 1-2 4-7 5-í> 5-14 44 Carlton . . . 1-1 1-1 2-2 3-4 22


N Melbourne " 0-2 2-2 2-4 C-5 41 Pt. Melbournes « 1-0 2-2 2-5 2-8 20

I ootscriv. ** - 2-1 2-4 2-8 2-10 22 Williamstown. - 0-2 0-2 0-J 0-4 4


i -Ú 5 S S I

í¿ i3 o ¿ £ £ Melbourne ----_?.?-?»__ 4 0 o 211 lil 1*1 Collingwood,. «-, *»-*, î 1 0 lft» 124 12 houth Melbourne «_-*. t 1 0 1(7 115 12 l_sscndoa *.*.._- J 1 0 107 11» 12 I it/roe., -.__,..-___ 2 2 0 174 1 ii « Geelong,-. _»._-.____, -_, 1 J 0 1>4 174 4 Carlton ._-,---,*,--. 0 4 0 _]r> 211 0 bU Kilda.. « " »... 0 4 0 t>0 -.42 0


Port Melbourne « »? 1 1 0 1)12 1-0 20 I-ootscraj " « " ft i o ^,i IJ\ 20 North Melbourne « « I î 0 "oil 212 12 »niTunkk M - MM 2 4 0 lio UL h Híchmond « ^. «... 1 i 1 _ti m o W illiamstow a-. - -« 1 4 1 ÎDJ ]D4 ü


POSITIONS or CLUBS \ î» io mrr


Atliirt pnrk .. .. H - West MellMiurnt» _» . Alantuirili. Jutnui- ». ]Ia«vi1inrn . ., - . ] 1171-0' Timiors ., -. CSollinirttoo«! Junior- . Alliion Unili-il _. _ . Itiriimollil Cit« .. » Jlojiil park Cres« cut " Tristón »..<»..

Results of matches played on Saturday :- Albert-   park v. Collingwood Juniors- Won by Albert-Park,     1 goal 8 behinds (14 points) to 7 behinds (7 points). Albion United v. Hawthorn-Won by   Hawthorn, 7 goals 7 behinds (49 ponts), to 3   goals 2 behinds (20 points). Fitzroy Juniors v.    

Royal-park Crescent-Won by Fitzroy Juniors, 4                 goals 8 behinds (32 points0, to 2 goals 1 behind       (13 points), Richmond City v. Montague Juniors-     -Won by Montague, 5 goals 8 behinds (38 points),    

to 3 goals 2 behinds (20 points). West Melbourne     v. Preston-Won by West Melbourne, 12 goals 6     behinds (78 points), to 2 goals 2 behinds (14   points).


BROKEN HILL, Sunday.  

Another football match yesterday ended in a dis-   graceful scene. A team of Victorian residents was       playing a South Australian team, and at the be-   ginning of the fourth quarter the scores were even. The crowd then rushed the ground, pressing the     players so much that they left the field in a body.   During the game several players came to blows.