Comments (None yet)

Add New Comment

4 corrections, most recently by Whitten - Show corrections


To the Editor of the Herald.    

SIR,—I have just travelled through the Bargo Brush,  

on the Great Southern Road, but such a road, I un-   hesitatingly say, never existed in any other civilized

or uncivilized part of the world. Dr. Leichhardt met with nothing like it on his overland journey to Port   Essington; nor did Bruce, in his travels in Abysinnia;       nor did Mungo Park, or Dr. Livingstone, in their

travels in the interior of Africa.  

To give any thing like a graphic description of the state of the road would be impossible. For about

twenty miles it is a succession of pits and bogs, and   holes of every kind, and in order to prevent the escape   of any of the unfortunate travellers into the bush, a

ditch has been cut on both sides of the road, so that   they are as well secured (although not so safe) as they would be on a treadmill. Every thing that nature   and art could do to render a road impassable and  

dangerous, has been done on the Great Southern   Road. Although I have had two days rest since     returned nome, I still feel appalled at the dangers I   have encountered, and most grateful to Providence

for my preservation of both life and limb. My friend   and I, who travelled together in a gig, determined   that we would spare no time or pains   in exploring—so as to perform (what appeared   to be a miracle)—the getting through this slough of   pits and bogs, without breaking a bone of man or   beast, or the shafts or springs of our gig. For this   purpose one led the horse and the other walked   before, to explore and take soundings of the pits,

bogs, &c.    

At times we were fairly brought to a stand-still, on   account of the almost unfathomable holes, and the   great number of drays, &c., deeply embedded in the   slough. The poor carriers appeared to be at their  

wits' end. I have never seen such a fine set of strong, healthy fellows so dead beat as were the car-   riers on this road. And I shall never forget their

kindness in assisting us in our difficulties. But for I them our horse and gig would have become a wreck on the Great Southern Road, and, probably, little

more than the whip would have been visible to act as   a beacon to warn travellers not to approach it. On one occasion, when we had got deeply bogged, I

asked a man, who was at the time hard at work with   a spade digging his dray out of a bog, to come and assist us. He immediately came, and also another     man, with whose help we saved the life of our horse.   Twice our horse got bogged up to the belly, notwith-   standing the utmost precautions we could use, and on    

one occasion broke a shaft, which we had to splice in   the best way we could with the reins, some straps, and saplings. One of the mail-driven told us that   one'of his wheelers had sunk to the hips, and was   with difficulty drawn out by the remainder of the

team. He said he had been twenty-two hours in   coming thirty-two miles, and that nothing should  

induce him to continue driving by night on such a       dangerous road.  

Is not this a case for Government interference ? If   any lives were lost on this road, would not Mr. Coroner   Parker (if he were to hold the inquest) commit the   Government to take their trial for manslaughter ?   And after all the honorable members of the Execu-   tive, and all the honorable members of the Legislative Assembly, and all the honorable members of the   Legislative Council had been publicly warned of the   extremely dangerous state of the road (which Mr.   Elworthy was not), and death were to ensue, would   not the Coroner be justified in sending the whole batch of them to Darlinghurst Gaol, and cautioning  

the constables on no account to take bail? I believe     we should hear no more of dangerous roads after Mr.     Coroner Parker had once filled Woolloomooloo Gaol   with our entire Executive and Legislative Government. But will not "free selection" be a mockery and a delusion without good roads ? Who would purchase land merely to grow wheat, barley, and oats; if he were shut out from a market by impassable roads, and thus unable either to dispose of his surplus produce, or purchase tea, sugar, and other necessaries? Nothing paralyzes industry more than bad roads. The rich lands to the southward, whose produce   would so abundantly feed the citizens of Sydney with the finest of wheat and the choicest English fruits, are now as valueless to the metropolis as so much space on the ocean. Without good roads no country can become prosperous, neither can the population become permanently and fully employed. This is clear, for, if by means of impassable roads you pre- vent people exchanging the products ot their industry with each other, you soon bring the labour of many of them to a stand-still. Some articles of export, which the normal capabilities of a country produce in per-   fection, may pay to be carried to port, over natural and artificial obstructions, but they are the exception, and commodities such as grain, which can be raised almost everywhere, must be brought to market by good roads, or it could only be sold as it was. It could not compete with that grown in other countries, under more favourable circumstances.

" Let the Government," said the great Dr. Smith, one hundred years ago, " direct all in attention to the en-   largement of the market, by forming safe and conven- ient roads." Now, what sort of a road is suitable for New South Wales at the present time, is a most important question. Some are of opinion that too much money cannot be spent upon the roads, and therefore advo- cate the expensive railroads. Others think that tramroads are amply sufficient in this colony for many years' to come. I decidedly incline to the latter opinion, and think it little short of madness to con- tinue the construction of expensive railroads, with

our sparse population and limited means. Look at the waste of power on the railroads already formed.   Every locomotive would, on the average, draw many times the number of passengers there are in each train, and the first-class carriages are seldom a quarter filled. On some parts of our   roads there are many times too much accommodation for travellers and goods, which has been provided at enormous cost to the country; on   other parts of our roads there are obstructions to transit of the most serious and formidable kind.

Tramroads are, unquestionably, the only kind of road adapted to this colony. We do not want high speed, but certainty, and the times of arrival and de- parture can be as well regulated by trams as rail- roads. The expensive railroads we cannot afford to pay for, and God forbid that any individual in this colony should entertain the idea of our borrowing enormous sums of English capitalists, and, afterwards repudiating, or suspending payment. We can afford to pay for tramroads. There is all the material on the ground. As we were stuck fast on the Bargo Brush, I could not help thinking, as I looked on the splendid ironbark trees, what an excellent tramroad they would make. And I also thought, what a pity it is, that the Government do not set to work, some of the many seeking employment in Sydney, in cutting down the timber and preparing it for sleepers and longitudinal rails.

With a little energy on the part of Government, and, of course, the assent of Parliament, how speedily a tramroad might be formed to Goulburn. How much temporary employment such work would give to the unemployed of Sydney, and how much permanent employment to the farmers in the country. If the Government determine to carry out their scheme of tramways, they must not expect that their chief engineer, Mr. Whitton, will ever sanction it. It would be as much as his professional reputation is worth to undertake any work of the kind. He would be twitted about his tramways as long as he lived. But there are plenty of men well qualified to construct tramways to be found. Mr. Hale had no difficulty in finding one, and the Government might easily get scores.

I consider the Government entitled to very great credit for the scheme of tramways they have sub- mitted to the Assembly. It is the wisest and best measure that ever was laid before Parliament, and I trust it will be carried. The only thing of which I complain is that it does not take precedence of the Land Bill and every other measure. A man must have a road to his land, or his land will be worthless. I will conclude this letter with a brief quotation from the greatest of all Political Economists, Dr. Adam Smith, who says,— ' It it evident, without any proof, that the erection and maintenance of the public works, which facilitate the commerce of a country, such as good roads, &c., must

require very different degrees of expense in the different     periods of society." It is clear that we are in that "period of society," when we can afford to construct tramroads, and when we cannot afford to pay the

interest on expensive railroads.  


Camden Villa, Newtown, 11th February.

Digitisation generously supported by
Vincent Fairfax Family Foundation
Digitisation generously supported by